By Jill Button, President & CEO, ProcurePro Consulting
A Practical Guide for 2025
As Canadian businesses increasingly expand across borders, managing payroll across multiple jurisdictions is becoming a complex, but essential, challenge. From compliance with CRA and provincial tax laws to navigating international privacy and employment regulations, the right payroll system can simplify operations, improve accuracy, and support strategic growth.
Whether you are a Canadian-based company with remote global workers or a multinational with offices globally, selecting the right payroll solution is no longer a back-office IT decision—it’s a core business imperative.
Why Payroll Software Selection is a Strategic Decision in 2025
The Canadian business environment is shifting rapidly, and payroll operations are under pressure from multiple directions:
- Hybrid and remote work models have increased cross-border employment, requiring payroll systems that manage multiple tax jurisdictions and currencies.
- Rising compliance complexity—from changes to CRA guidelines to international data privacy legislation like GDPR—demands more robust payroll capabilities.
- Labour mobility and talent shortages are driving companies to hire internationally, often before their payroll infrastructure is ready.
- The federal election may also impact employment standards, cross-border trade, and digital data rules, all of which intersect with payroll compliance.
The payroll tools that served a regional business in 2020 may no longer be sufficient for a company operating across time zones and tax codes in 2025.
Common Challenges Faced by Canadian Businesses (Local and Global)
We’ve worked with clients at every stage, from local startups to global organizations scaling across the U.S., Europe, Australia and Asia-Pacific. Here are the key challenges we frequently encounter:
A) Limited International Capabilities
Many popular Canadian payroll systems are not built for multi-country use. Companies often discover too late that their provider can’t handle tax reporting, statutory benefits, or payments in new markets.
B) Disconnected Systems Across Countries
Using disparate payroll systems in each country often results in fragmented data, inconsistent reporting, and governance issues. This leads to inefficiencies, security risks, and additional internal overhead.
C) Data Privacy and Residency Concerns
International data residency regulations (e.g., GDPR in Europe, PIPEDA in Canada and now Quebec Law 25, similar to GDPR) can conflict. Organizations must ensure their payroll provider complies with the most restrictive rules to avoid fines or reputational damage.
D) Lack of Standardized Global Reporting
When payroll systems differ across countries, consolidating global payroll data for finance and HR reporting becomes a manual and error-prone task—especially during audits or financial planning.
E) Hidden Costs and Tax Risks
Currency fluctuations, misclassification of contractors, and lack of in-country compliance expertise can all lead to costly penalties, especially when operating without localized support.
Five Strategic Steps to Select the Right Payroll System
Whether you operate exclusively in Canada or across multiple countries, the following five-step approach will help ensure you select the right payroll software for long-term success.
Step 1: Define Your Workforce and Geographic Requirements
Start with clarity:
- How many employees are in Canada, and how many are in each country or jurisdiction?
- What types of workers do you pay (full-time, part-time, contractors)?
- Do you require compliance with bilingual laws in Quebec, provincial, state or country-specific regulations?
- Will you need multi-currency payroll, global tax reporting, or localized payslips?
Tip: If you’re using contractors, be aware of local worker classification laws. Misclassification can result in significant penalties.
Step 2: Evaluate Canada-Based and Global Suppliers
Not all payroll suppliers are equipped for international scale. As a Canadian business, consider whether you need:
- A Canada-focused supplier (e.g., Wagepoint, Rise, Collage, Humi, Payworks)
- A global payroll provider (e.g., ADP, Ceridian, Neeyamo)
- A hybrid model that combines in-country partners with centralized reporting
Key features to look for:
- Country-specific tax compliance
- Multi-currency and FX support
- Consolidated global dashboards
- Payroll only or comprehensive Human Capital Management (HCM)
- Integration with HR, time tracking, and finance tools
- Localized support and SLAs
- Data residency (where will your data be stored?)
Step 3: Build a Formal RFP and Evaluation Process
Avoid relying on demos alone. A structured Request for Proposal (RFP) should:
- Define specific use cases across each country
- Ask for detailed implementation timelines
- Request references from similar Canadian businesses with global operations
- Include security, compliance, and data residency requirements
- Capture total cost of ownership (TCO), including recurring fees; license, managed services, maintenance and one-time fees; implementation, training. FX fees and per-country costs
At ProcurePro, we provide tailored RFP templates, requirements and supplier evaluation support to help you through this complex process.
Step 4: Prepare a Global Implementation Plan
Multi-country payroll implementation involves more than just software deployment:
- Align internal stakeholders (HR, finance, compliance, IT) across all locations
- Assign dedicated project leads and subject matter experts for each country or region
- Validate data migration and ensure pay group structures are correct
- Provide localized training and documentation for each team
Implementation timelines will vary based on complexity. A single-country payroll deployment may take 8–12 weeks. A multi-country rollout can take 4–6 months or more depending on the number of jurisdictions.
Step 5: Establish Ongoing Governance and Risk Monitoring
Once live, your system must support:
- Global compliance audits
- Country-specific payroll calendars and remittance dates
- Quarterly supplier performance reviews with key performance indicator (KPI) tracking
- Data privacy impact assessments (particularly if you’re processing, Quebec, EU or U.S. employee data)
Set KPIs for:
- Payroll accuracy rate
- Processing time per country
- FX cost management
- Compliance alerts resolved
Payroll Technology Trends Canadian Companies Should Watch
Several trends are reshaping the payroll landscape, especially for global-ready businesses:
A) Unified Global Payroll Platforms
Solutions that consolidate multi-country payroll under one dashboard are gaining traction. These platforms reduce manual reconciliation, support centralized reporting, and simplify supplier management.
B) Embedded AI for Risk Detection
AI tools are helping organizations identify outliers in payroll (e.g., unusual bonus amounts, duplicate entries), flagging potential compliance risks before they escalate.
C) Increased Adoption of Employer of Record (EOR) Services
For Canadian firms hiring internationally without establishing a local legal entity, EOR platforms like Deel, Oyster, or Remote offer compliant employment infrastructure while offloading administrative burdens.
D) Stricter Global Data Privacy Rules
With the emergence of legislation like GDPR, Canada’s PIPEDA, Quebec Law 25, and U.S. state-level privacy laws, payroll data handling is under increasing scrutiny. Companies must ensure their systems meet all applicable jurisdictions’ privacy requirements.
Conclusion: Build a Payroll Infrastructure That Supports Growth
Canadian businesses, especially those expanding globally, must move beyond legacy systems and spreadsheets. Whether operating domestically or internationally, the risks associated with poor payroll execution are significant: non-compliance fines, employee dissatisfaction, and reputational damage.
A modern, compliant, and scalable payroll solution provides a foundation for operational resilience and supports both workforce flexibility and business agility.
If your business expansion includes new markets, onboarding remote employees, or upgrading existing payroll systems, it’s time to take a strategic approach to selection and implementation.
If you’re looking for expert support to navigate your Payroll selection ProcurePro Consulting is here to help. Setup time with me for an exploratory discussion and let’s craft a strategy that works for your business.
Check out other great articles including Writing Effective RFP Requirements
Subscribe to our IT ProcurePro Newsletter on Substack for more IT Procurement best practices, supplier insights, and digital transformation strategies.
Learn more about our Procurement Advisory Services at www.procurepro.ca